@oddpedestrian
I totally understand the OP on this and the impact. yeah the fight really is not worth fighting. if your CO though will go to bat for you like that (providing your Active duty and not being used as a backdoor to fire you as an AGR) get the fit and stay on active duty, but if your a National Guardsman/Reservist on a full time Active Guard Reserve Order this is their backdoor I'd call it. and also It would depend on what the impact statement says and do the performance evals and documentation match the commander's statement.... that is a gray area, and it depends on what conditions the member has.. if it's mental and he or she is getting hit with referral EPR's because of mistakes being classified as substandard duty performance... that would be a case for rebuttal, but if said member only has physical limitations and gets the same referral evals then the member would not have a case to refute the impact statement. does that make any sense?