SFC H,
As for the 90% rating; that's for your PTSD (50%); Bilateral Knee (19%); how did you get your 90% total.
I'm trying to finalize all my claims and hopefully stay under radar before I get MEDBOARDED.
TO FILE VA CLAIM IN MEB OR NOT
- Thread starter SFC H
- Start date
SFC H,
As for the 90% rating; that's for your PTSD (50%); Bilateral Knee (19%); how did you get your 90% total.
I'm trying to finalize all my claims and hopefully stay under radar before I get MEDBOARDED.
How would one claim SMC-K if they have ED? Is it claimed after the service or during the MEB process?
My VA claim was submitted 20+ years after I retired (regular retirement).
I submitted a DBQ and a diagnosis from my urologist after prostate cancer surgery. This was all related to Agent Orange exposure in Vietnam.
I did not experience a MEB.
SMC-K = about $108 monthly.
Ron
187thINF,
I think I confused you. My disability ratings are as follows.
VA 90% STATIC Rating
PTSD 70%
OSA 50%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
TINNITUS 10%
DOD 60% Rating
PTSD 50%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
I think I confused you. My disability ratings are as follows.
VA 90% STATIC Rating
PTSD 70%
OSA 50%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
TINNITUS 10%
DOD 60% Rating
PTSD 50%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
An ED claim would be most likely be claimed secondary to another claim. IE: Like when you are prescribed medication that has side effects such as ED. The claim is initiated like any other condition through E-benefits, VSO or MEB process. On a side note, this condition not considered unfitting so it would only help your VA percentage and not your DOD percentage.
That is precisely what occurred in my case.
ED was secondary to prostate cancer and surgery.
There is not a rating percentage for ED other than zero. "Generally, the VA will grant a 0-percent rating for erectile dysfunction . However, service connection for erectile dysfunction, even at 0 percent, makes veterans eligible for Special Monthly Compensation (SMC-K) for loss of use of a creative organ."
Ron
SFC H; have you applied for the Gulf War Registry? I just went through the process today; and there are several conditions eligible for compensation; presumptive conditions.
I am well aware that ED is not an unfitting condition but rather a condition that can be claimed as SMC-K. Going back to my original question, how would one claim SMC-K? Can this be claimed through the MEB process when first meeting your appointed MSC or after the service? Thank you for any input.
I haven't registered as of yet. Do you mind sharing the conditions?
The claim is filed like any other claim and if found service connected, the VA would grant 0% like RonG previously posted. They then grant SMC-K for loss of a reproductive organ.
SFC H, For the Gulf War/Environmental IBS, GERT, Migraines , ect.
www.publichealth.va.gov
VA.gov | Veterans Affairs
Apply for and manage the VA benefits and services you’ve earned as a Veteran, Servicemember, or family member—like health care, disability, education, and more.
I claimed ED secondary to hypogonadism and low-t.... I was approved for SMC-K and 0% linked to hypogonadism and dual testicular atrophy and the ED was dropped.
Was PTSD your referred condition or your knees?
Both PTSD and bilateral knees were IDES referred
Wanted to post an update, IBS @ 30% was granted and Hypertension was denied yet again. VSO said I can write a supporting statement for Hypertension and he will submit a higher level review claim, so that not completely dead yet.
PREVIOUSLY
VA 90% STATIC Rating
PTSD 70%
OSA 50%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
TINNITUS 10%
CURRENTLY
VA 90% STATIC Rating
PTSD 70%
OSA 50%
IBS 30%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
TINNITUS 10%
I have other injuries that I wish I could claim but my stupid self didn’t go to sick call and get them documented. [Broken nose with recent corrective surgery and a pinched nerve in my shoulder that causes three fingers to go numb when ever it feels like it]. Not giving up yet.
SFC H
PREVIOUSLY
VA 90% STATIC Rating
PTSD 70%
OSA 50%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
TINNITUS 10%
CURRENTLY
VA 90% STATIC Rating
PTSD 70%
OSA 50%
IBS 30%
L KNEE 10%
R KNEE 10%
BILATERAL for both knees 1.9%
TINNITUS 10%
I have other injuries that I wish I could claim but my stupid self didn’t go to sick call and get them documented. [Broken nose with recent corrective surgery and a pinched nerve in my shoulder that causes three fingers to go numb when ever it feels like it]. Not giving up yet.
SFC H
Hey SFC H, first off, thank you for your incredible 24 years of service, Desert Storm, OIF, the whole nine yards. That's a serious commitment.
Regarding your MEB/VA strategy: I strongly recommend following your Military Service Coordinator's advice: sign the 21-4138 and do NOT file new claims right now. You already have a robust 90% rating. Introducing new claims (Hypertension, ED, etc.) into the MEB/IDES process complicates things significantly and, more importantly, can trigger a full review and new C&P exams for all your existing ratings. The risk of a reduction, though small, is not worth the potential speed bump.
Your best move is to let the MEB focus only on the "unfit" conditions (PTSD and Knees) to finalize your separation and benefits. Once you are officially retired/separated, immediately file a Notice of Intent to File (NOI) for the other conditions. You can then file the ED as a secondary claim linked to your PTSD medication, and the knee increase after your surgery. This strategic timing protects your current 90% rating while ensuring you get compensated for everything you deserve later. Good luck with the process, brother.
Regarding your MEB/VA strategy: I strongly recommend following your Military Service Coordinator's advice: sign the 21-4138 and do NOT file new claims right now. You already have a robust 90% rating. Introducing new claims (Hypertension, ED, etc.) into the MEB/IDES process complicates things significantly and, more importantly, can trigger a full review and new C&P exams for all your existing ratings. The risk of a reduction, though small, is not worth the potential speed bump.
Your best move is to let the MEB focus only on the "unfit" conditions (PTSD and Knees) to finalize your separation and benefits. Once you are officially retired/separated, immediately file a Notice of Intent to File (NOI) for the other conditions. You can then file the ED as a secondary claim linked to your PTSD medication, and the knee increase after your surgery. This strategic timing protects your current 90% rating while ensuring you get compensated for everything you deserve later. Good luck with the process, brother.