Med Board Question

trishnron

PEB Forum Regular Member
PEB Forum Veteran
I am currently active duty and I was on Limited Duty (LIMDU) for approx 11 months. I was told that I need to get off of LIMDU because if I go beyond a year my record will go before a medical board. I was told that it is not a good thing because being medically retired or PDRL or TDRL will be alot less than your regular pension, Is this true?. I am approx 7yrs reserves and 11 years of active duty. When I went to see the doctor to clear me for full duty he asked me how I was feeling, I told I felt good to go, but when I did a certain excersises I felt some pain. Then he proceeded to show me were the pain was at and he could see it on the MRI that I have a pretty good tear in my hip and that I needed to get surgery. I refused the surgery because I was not having servere pain as of now,and to keep me from going back on LIMDU and having my record before the board. Before I left the office he asked me 3 times if I was sure that I didnt want the surgery and I said yes. Now I am back on sea duty and the pain is starting to be a nuisance. My medical condition along with the hip which happened all at the same time (Knee Surgery, ruptured aductor previs and a 70% torn aductor longus(groin muscles and torn groin muscle), and Torn Hip). I know that I will need another knee scope because this is starting to swell again. I am kinda scared to go back to medical and have me record go before the Board. My question is what will happen if this goes up to the board? Will you get two seperate pays from the DOD and VA? This all just happened within the past 15months. Will I lose medical benefits for my family if I go on PDRL or TDRL? What benefits do you recieve? Thanks for any inputs!
 
I am currently active duty and I was on Limited Duty (LIMDU) for approx 11 months. I was told that I need to get off of LIMDU because if I go beyond a year my record will go before a medical board. I was told that it is not a good thing because being medically retired or PDRL or TDRL will be alot less than your regular pension, Is this true?.

If you are retired, it is based on your high3 (average of your last 36 months of active duty pay), so no, this is not true.



My question is what will happen if this goes up to the board?
They will determine whether you are fit or unfit. Fitness will result in return to duty, unfitness will result in a determination of your benefits. If rated at 30% or more you will be medically retired.


Will you get two seperate pays from the DOD and VA?
Generally,no. But if your conditions are combat related or you have more than 20 years of service (which you said you do not), you can receive at least partial pay from both sources.


Will I lose medical benefits for my family if I go on PDRL or TDRL?
No, if you are medically retired from the military, you receive the same medical benefits as a length of service active duty retiree (including for your eligible dependents).
 
Jason thanks so much for the quick response. This forum has answered alot of questions. I will keep you posted on the outcomes and the process....Thanks again!!

Ron
 
Jason,
I have another question. I was on 2 periods of LIMDU and I am currently in transiet to my next command. If I go to medical on a previous injury that was connected to those periods of LIMDU will I go straight to a MEB? I had a groing adductor brevis rupture, Adductor longus torn, knee surgery and that is why I was on LIMDU for 2 periods. But now the doctor told me I have a tear in my hip that will require surgery they might be connect to the same accident but different injury. If I get the surgery and go on LIMDU again what do you think will happen?
 
It really depends on the outcome of the surgery. They will want to give you time to heal and recover so if you do go to an MEB you are at an optimal condition. If the surgery is a success, you might be returned to full duty.
 
Thanks for the response....I just found out last week that they need to do a Miniscus Transplant so I will probably be waiting for a donor for a while. Then after I recover from that then they will do the hip surgery but in the meantime I will get shots in the hip....great....I never even heard of miniscus transplants before. So I have a while before this will go before the board. This will be my 3rd Limdu...I will keep everyone posted on the outcome...
 
Well I got word on friday that they could have a donor and that I could have the surgery in the next two weeks. I also got word on friday that PERS wants to do a admin seperation on me because I am not deployable. My paperwork is in for my 3rd limdu but is waiting a CA(Convening Authority) signature. The reason I am getting the 2nd surgery is because the doc messed up on the first one....So I have a new doc now....But i did not think they could Admin seperate me. Can they admin seperate you on LIMDU? and pending a surgery?
 
I just got the CA Approval and now my paperwork need to go to departmental review for final approval for my third limdu. I know this will go up to MED and PEB after I heel. I just didnt understand why they tried to adsep me before my surgery. Anyone have any Ideas? Also does anyone know if they can adsep you while on Limdu?
 
I'm not sure whether they can adsep one while they are on LIMDU; however, I have known folks who they have tried to adsep before their MEB/PEB. I would assume that the logic is quite straightforward: adsep a servicemember before they are found disabled and you save a lot of money, especially if they are found over 30%.
 
I agree the Navy is trying to save money by trying to adsep. I did get them to put that on hold because I can not pass a seperation physical pending a surgery. So now they sent off a message sending me to MEB after my surgery and Rehab. I will have to wait and see what happens after that. Thanks for the input...
 
I am currently going on my 4th LIMDU period because I have about a year of REHAB. They PEBLO would like me to fill out the Non-medical Assesment and route via my chain of command. I guess they need this to present to the PEB....and the process begins...I also had to have the doctor fill out his dictation for my 4th. All this needs to go to PERS for approval. I am wondering what will happen if the don't? does anyone know?? I still have to finish my rehab and pass a separation physical right?? I have looked to see what a disability rating is for a Medial Meniscus Transplant and can not find anything. Does anyone have any Idea?? any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks
 
Most likely the rating would be based on disability of knee and limitation of range of motion.
 
They don't always wait for members to reach optimal level of health...sometimes we don't progress fast enough, so they just kick us out before they even figure out what is going on!
 
I just found out yesterday they are starting the MEB/PEB process and will not approve the 4th period of LIMDU. They asked for my medical record and they are copying it. The NMA is getting signed this week which puts me in favor of staying in(I hope). With all my medical conditions, what do you think for a possiblility of staying in if you where to sit this board? also any idea on disability percentage and time frame?

Right knee meniscus transplant
Complete Rupture of adductor brevis muscle(groin muscle)
Tear of the adductor longus (groin muscle)
Torn Laberal (right Hip)
Hypertension on medication
 
I just finished all my VA Appts and I also just got diagnosed with OSA (Obstructive Sleep Apnea). With all the other conditions is OSA considered to be a Unfitting Condition? I will have to be put on CPAP which i am not too happy about. Does anyone have any insight on this?
 
Also with the other conditions what do you think the outcome is going to be on the IPEB?? any insight will help. I have a appointment with the doc that is going to be doing the wright up on for the MEB/IPEB. Does anyone have any suggestions because I am trying to stay in the service.
 
Generally OSA is not service disqualifying for the Navy. Hell it's not even Sub disqualifying. As far as fit or unfit, any speculation would be a waste. In the last 2 years I have seen the same diagnosis come back both ways, it all depends on the board members. Either way, having a positive NMA does have an impact.
 
Top